If Buddy is barking at you to fill his bowl, listen up.
He may also be speaking up to demand a switch in his daily dinner, or breakfast and lunch too, for that matter.
Since we all love our fur babies as our own, what we feed them matters. Finding the right kibble can be difficult, as there is a sea of choices for pooches of all shapes and sizes with less-than-helpful packaging and guidance.
The first step when choosing a dog food is to consult your local vet, as they know what is best for their favorite, slobbery patients. However, for those that want even more recommended or even a place to start before your annual visit, we have that covered.
- Best Overall: Freshpet Vital Chicken Recipe Fresh Dog Food
- Best for Puppies: Purina Pro Plan High Protein Chicken & Rice Formula Dry Puppy Food
- Best for Small Breeds: Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Small Breed Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food
- Best for Large Breeds: Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Large Breed Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food
- Best for Sensitive Stomachs: Orijen Amazing Grains Puppy Dry Dog Food
We spoke with Dr. Danielle Bernal, a veterinarian for Wellness Pet Company as well as Dr. Katy Nelson, senior veterinarian at Chewy about what to look for in a dog food formula, what to avoid, and also any tips and tricks for choosing the right chow for your Chihuahua and the best munchies for your Maltese.
Keep reading to see Dr. Nelson’s top dog food recommendations or jump to our FAQ to learn more about the best ingredients (and the worst) to feed your pooch.
Best Dog Food Brands
RELATED: Best dog products, according to Cesar Millan
Best Overall: Freshpet Vital Chicken Recipe Fresh Dog Food
Pros:
- Non-GMO ingredients
- Good for small and large breeds
- Works for dogs with sensitive stomachs
Cons:
- Only four pouches come in a case
“I’ve been feeding Freshpet to my pups for years!” said Dr. Nelson. “I love that the only preservative that they use is your refrigerator. Fresh, natural ingredients are used and they’re slowly steamed to preserve the maximum nutrient availability.”
This expert pick made the list, as this is what Dr. Nelson feeds her own furry family member. The Freshpet collection can be found on Chewy, including the chicken recipe pictured above.
Size options: 1.75 pound bag | Flavor: Chicken
Best Pantry Fresh: JustFoodforDogs
Pros:
- Human-grade meal
- Free of BHA, BHT, growth hormones and artificial colorings
Cons:
- May not appeal to finicky dogs
“This brand has some great fresh and frozen recipes including JustFoodForDogs Fish & Sweet Potato Recipe Frozen Human-Grade Fresh Dog Food which is a high-protein, low-calorie recipe promoting healthy weight and crafted with fresh, human-grade ingredients including wild-caught Alaskan cod, sweet potatoes, broccoli and green beans,” said Dr. Nelson, using Chewy’s Fresh and Prepared Food Finder for help.
Like the brand says, this shop is just for dogs and puppies. Shop the full selection at Chewy.com, making sure to take a look at the variety pack listed above.
Size options: Available in 5.5-72 ounce pouches (cases vary) | Flavors: Beef & Turkey, Beef & Russet Potato, Chicken & White Rice, Fish & Sweet Potato, Venison & Squash, Lamb & Brown Rice, Turkey & Whole Wheat Macaroni, Sampler Variety Pack
Best for Small Breeds: Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Small Breed Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food
Pros:
- Almost a five star rating on Chewy
- No wheat, soy, corn or meat by-product
- Chicken is first ingredient
Cons:
- Overall, the majority of reviews are positive for this dog food. However, some pet owners found that their dogs did not take to the food’s flavor
For smaller dogs, such as Frenchies and terriers, try something like this from Blue Buffalo. It’s first ingredient is meat, which is important when shopping a dog food brand. “You then want to see ingredients you recognize,” said Dr. Bernal.
The kibble size isn’t too big, so smaller mouths don’t need to struggle to get a proper mouthful. The formula is also filled with antioxidants, Glucosamine for joint mobility, and omegas for a glossy coat.
Size options: Available in 5-15 pound bags | Flavors: Chicken & Brown Rice, Lamb & Brown Rice
Best for Puppies: Purina Pro Plan High Protein Chicken & Rice Formula Dry Puppy Food
Pros:
- Meat is the first ingredient
- Has vitamin A and omega-6 fatty acids to keep your dog’s coat soft and shiny
- Promotes joint health
Cons:
- Only two flavor options
“The recipe is crafted with high-quality protein, including chicken as the #1 ingredient to help build lean muscles and the food includes glucosamine and EPA, an omega-3 fatty acid, for joint health and mobility,” said Dr. Nelson. “Plus, vitamin A and omega-6 fatty acids will help nourish your pup’s skin and coat.”
This dry dog food is sold in a variety of sizes from six to 34 pounds, lasting your pup a while until they become a big kid… well, big dog.
Size options: Available in 6-34 pound bags | Flavors: Chicken & Rice, Lamb & Rice
Best for Large Breeds: Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Large Breed Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food
Pros:
- Calcium and phosphorus for teeth and bone health
- High protein content from meat and eggs
- Budget-friendly dog food brand
Cons:
- Some customers noted that there are tinier bits of kibble mixed in that their dogs didn’t like
Similarly, if you own a bigger dog, such as a golden retriever or mastiff, Blue Buffalo has an option for them, too. We like the option made with deboned chicken, whole grains, fruits and vegetables. However, there’s also a lamb favor if your pooch is fancy!
Size options: Available in 15-34 pound bags | Flavors: Chicken & Brown, Lamb & Brown Rice,
Best for Sensitive Stomachs: Orijen Amazing Grains Puppy Dry Dog Food
Pros:
- Flax seed for digestion
- Prebiotics and probiotics
- First seven ingredients are animal-based protein, including wild-caught fish
Cons:
- Specific formula is for puppies. Check out other dog food options from Orijen
“With 4.9 stars, ORIJEN Amazing Grains Puppy Dry Dog Food is specially crafted to meet the nutritional needs of your growing puppy and protein-packed with poultry and fish to support your pup’s muscle development,” said Dr. Nelson. “This food also supports your dog’s digestive health with prebiotics and probiotics—soluble and insoluble fiber from inulin—and a premium grain blend.”
ORIJEN is sold at Chewy in a variety of flavors and sizes, with this dry food kibble coming in a small four-pound bag and a larger 22.5-pound bag.
Size options: Available in 4-22.5 pound bags | Flavor: N/A
Best Freeze-Dried: Open Farm Turkey Freeze Dried Raw Dog Food
Pros:
- Made from free-range turkey and organic produce
- Omega-3 and 6 for coat health
Cons:
- Meat isn’t organic
For those of you who’d like to prepare your dog fresh meals every day, consider this a less labor intensive alternative. The dog food is freeze-dried to maintain nutritional freshness, and features a host of organic veggies and fruits. Most importantly, the first three ingredients are turkey, providing a healthy dose of protein for your K9.
Size options: Available in 3.50-22 ounce bags | Flavor: Turkey Recipe
Best Grain-Free Dog Food: Wellness CORE Puppy (Grain Free)
Pros:
- Fortified with vitamins and minerals
- Taurine for heart health
- Good for large and small dog breeds
Cons:
- While also listed as appropriate for adult and senior dogs, we couldn’t find reviews from owners with either. Because of this, we recommend checking Wellness CORE (Grain-Free) for adult dogs
“CORE recipes are crafted based on the nutritional philosophy that dogs, based on their primal ancestry, thrive on a natural diet mainly comprised of meat. Packed with premium protein along with nutrient-rich superfoods and nutritional supplements to ensure your puppy has everything they need to thrive from the CORE,” said Dr. Bernal.
Starting at $20 for the four-pound bag, the dry kibble can be ordered to pick up in store, or shipped to your home for easy feeding.
Size options: Available in 4-26 pound bags | Flavor: Chicken & Turkey Recipe
Best for Coat Health: American Journey Puppy Lamb & Sweet Potato Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
Pros:
- Contains healthy fats
- Also available in the flavor chicken & lamb
- Doesn’t contain soy or corn
Cons:
- One reviewer mentioned having an issue resealing the bag. To keep your dog’s dry food fresh, consider using a sealable container, like the Frisco Airtight Food storage Container ($14).
“This high-protein dog food with real, deboned lamb is not only delicious for your pup but full of amino acids that help maintain lean muscle mass, plus salmon oil and flaxseed provide omega-3 and 6 fatty acids, including long-chain DHA, help support your dog’s skin and coat health and brain and eye development,” said Dr. Nelson.
There are an array of sizes to order, should you shop at Chewy. We love the option to bundle and save, with two four-pound packages or two 12-pound bags, shipped right to your door.
Size options: Available in 12-24 pound bags | Flavors: Chicken & Sweet Potato, Lamb & Sweet Potato
Best Dog Food for Senior Dogs: Wellness CORE Digestive Health Age Advantage (grained)
Pros:
- Contains superfoods and omega fatty acids
- Good for gut health
- Promotes firmer stools
Cons:
- Kibble size is on the larger side, which may be an issue for smaller dogs
“Designed specifically for the needs of senior dogs, Wellness CORE Digestive Health Age Advantage is a highly digestible, probiotic-coated kibble crafted with a unique blend of prebiotic fibers to support digestive health. This recipe is made with guaranteed levels of Glucosamine, Chondroitin Sulfate, and Calcium to support healthy joints and bones. So, every dog, at any age, can live their best life,” said Dr. Bernal.
Size options: Available in 4-24 pound bags | Flavor: Chicken & Brown Rice
Best for Small Senior Dogs: Hill’s Science Diet Adult 7+ Small Bites Chicken Meal, Barley & Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food
Pros:
- No artificial flavors, preservatives or colors
- First ingredient is chicken
- Easy on dog’s digestion
Cons:
- Only available in one flavor
“This is an easy-to-digest food for senior dogs who prefer a smaller kibble size. Its synergistic ingredient blend encourages youthful vitality and promotes an ideal weight,” said Dr. Nelson.
This best senior dog food comes in small bites come in many sizes, from a small five-pound bag to the largest 33-pound package, all sold on Chewy’s site.
Size options: Available in 5-33 pound bags | Flavor: Chicken Meal, Barley & Rice Recipe
Best Splurge: American Journey Senior Chicken & Sweet Potato Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
Pros:
- Contains a variety of vitamins and minerals, including Taurine and L-Carnitine
- Also available in the flavor Salmon & Sweet potato
- More than 1,000 five star reviews on Chewy
Cons:
- Only available in 24 pound bag
“This is a grain-free senior dry dog food that helps support healthy aging with real chicken as the first ingredient, plus a blend of targeted nutrients. Its antioxidant blend helps support a healthy immune system while omega fatty acids help maintain skin and coat health and medium chain triglycerides naturally occurring in coconut oil help support brain health in aging dogs to encourage cognitive wellness,” said Dr. Nelson.
No need to journey to the store, either, as Chewy can ship this 24-pound bag of kibble right to your home. You can also set up an Autoship subscription, saving more time and money when you need a refill.
Size options: Available in 24 pound bag | Flavors: Chicken & Sweet Potato, Salmon & Sweet Potato
Best for Weight Loss: Wellness Complete Health Healthy Weight
Pros:
- Non-GMO ingredients
- Calcium and phosphorus for healthy teeth and gums
- Available in four flavors at Chewy
Cons:
- Some customers reviews noted that it did not agree with their dog’s digestive system
“This natural dry food for dogs is specially formulated with reduced calories and lowered total fat to support healthy weight loss and weight maintenance in less active or overweight adult dogs,” said Dr. Bernal.
Keeping your pet’s weight under control is no small feat, which is why the vets recommended this kibble made with nutrient-rich whole foods to fill up your pup.
Size options: Available in 5-30 pound bags | Flavors: Beef & Barley, Deboned Chicken & Oatmeal, Lamb & Barley, Whitefish & Sweet Potatoe
Best Wet Food for Weight Loss: Hill’s Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Hearty Vegetable & Chicken Stew Canned Dog Food
Pros:
- Smells good
- No artificial colors or preservatives
- Includes organ meat
Cons:
- One customer complained that the ratio of peas and carrots were too high
“If you’re looking for canned food, this is a good pick as its lean and delicious recipe delivers 100% precisely balanced nutrition and contains prebiotic fibers for gentle digestion,” said Dr. Nelson. “When fed this nutrition, over 70% of dogs lost weight within 10 weeks adding not only to their life expectancy but also their overall quality of life.”
We wanted to add in an option for wet dog food, should yours prefer the whole and hearty taste of vegetable and chicken stew, sold in a package of 12 or 24.
Size options: Available in 12.5-12.8 ounce cans (case of 12) | Flavors: Chicken & Vegetables, Hearty Vegetables & Chicken
Best for Allergies: Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Skintopic Adult Dry Dog Food
Pros:
- Single source carbohydrate
- Hydrolyzed Protein
Cons:
- First ingredient isn’t meat but the second is hydrolyzed chicken liver
No one likes being itchy — even dogs. For Fido’s allergies, go with Royal Canin. It has a Dermauxilium Complex for skin health, as well as highly hydrolyzed protein to promote better stools and digestion. The food also has a host of vitamins and minerals.
Size options: Available in 8-25 pound bags | Flavors: N/A
Best Dog Food for Sensitive Stomaches: Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets EN Gastroenteric Dry Dog Food
Pros:
- Ingredients to aid in nutrient absorption
- Appropriate for puppies and older dogs
Cons:
- Meat is not the first ingredient but second
“With a With a 4.8 rating, this is a great-tasting dry dog food for a healthy GI tract featuring MCT vegetable or coconut oil. The recipe was developed in collaboration with nutritionists, researchers and veterinarians using high-quality ingredients including prebiotic fiber and healthy antioxidants and designed to promote optimal nutrient absorption and total digestibility,” said Dr. Nelson.
This formula not only has the vet’s stamp of approval, but the star-rating to back it up with customer satisfaction. The bag of dry food comes in a variety of sizes, from a five-pound bag all the way up to a 32-pound amount.
Size options: Available in 6-12 pound bags | Flavor: N/A
Best for High-Protein: Iams Minichunks High-Protein with Real Lamb Dry Dog Food
Pros:
- Lots of sizes to choose from
- Three optional flavors
- No artificial flavoring or preservatives
Cons:
- Not suggested for puppies under one year
Infused with antioxidants to improve immune health, this recipe also features omega-6 fatty acids to promote vibrant skin and a lustrous, healthy coat. It has three flavors available and comes in a variety of sizes depending on your dog’s breed and weight.
Best Topper: Stella & Chewy’s Chewy’s Chicken Meal Mixers Freeze-Dried Raw Dog Food Topper
Pros:
- A wide variety of flavors
- Available in bundles
Cons:
- Not intended as a meal replacement
Topping your dog’s food is a great way to add extra nutrients without significantly increasing the cost per meal, unlike pricier options like Farmer’s Dog or Spot & Tango fresh food delivery services. This option offers a variety of flavors, sizes, and bundle deals to suit your dog’s needs.
Best Wet for Puppies: Royal Canin Size Health Nutrition
Pros:
- Best for infant puppies
Cons:
- Not created for all ages
- Small variety to choose from
For those newborns gradually transitioning from their mother’s milk, this gentle formula crafted from an ultra-soft mouse ensures an easy and enticing feeding experience. Each can contains 5.1 ounces and is available in a case of 24.
Best Wet for Seniors: Royal Canin Mature 8+ Canned Dog Food
Pros:
- Best for small mature dogs
- Great for added hydration
Cons:
- Not designed for large breed dogs
As your dog ages, its dietary needs may change. Royal Canin incorporates antioxidants and vitamins into its formula to promote cellular health while maintaining its delicious taste. It’s conveniently packaged in 5.2-ounce cans and is available in a case of 24.
Best Strong Immune System for Seniors: VICTOR Purpose Senior Healthy Weight Dry Dog Food
Pros:
- Created for senior dogs and their energy needs
- Promotes a strong and healthy immune and digestive system
Cons:
- None that we found
Joint health is crucial for your dear aging pup. “In general, [senior dogs] will have lower energy requirements, lower dietary phosphorus needs, we want to restrict dietary sodium, quality protein source (lower if kidney disease is an issue) and increase in fiber,” said Dr. Hockaday.
This 15-pound bag has prebiotics and probiotics to strengthen the dog’s immune and digestive system and focuses on mineral complexes to regulate the metabolism. Dr. Hockaday said that “the prebiotic effects of grains in both diets are very beneficial to maintain healthy gut flora in large-breed dogs.”
FAQ
How to choose a good dog food?
There are a bunch of factors that go into choosing the right food for your dog, many of which will be addressed by your vet. If not, we also got expert intel from Dr. Bernal, breaking it down into simple steps — trust of the brand, nutrition, ingredients and format. We’ll get into a lot of this later, but here are a few tips.
- [Look for] trust in its manufacturing practices, food safety processes and quality assurance programs
- See if the brand has undergone AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials) testing and meets requirements
- Dry vs. wet food? Neither is the better format, as both have benefits. For example, dry recipes deliver more nutrient dense nutrition while wet recipes have a high moisture content.
What ingredients should I look for?
The ingredients list of a dog food bag can be confusing, with buzz words like “healthy,” “raw,” and “organic” thrown around. But what ingredients should we really be looking for when choosing a substantive and delicious dish for your dog?
“Look for [bags that] include fresh meat as the first ingredient, concentrated meat meals as second and or third ingredients,” said Dr. Bernal. “You then want to see ingredients you recognize.”
In addition, other vitamins and minerals are important for well-rounded health of your pup, said Dr. Nelson.
“Amino acids, which build and repair tissues, help maintain healthy skin and coat and support the immune system; fatty acids, which also maintain healthy skin and coat, and are essential for joint health and a healthy immune system. Vitamins and minerals are important to ensure that the pet’s nutrient requirements are met,” she said.
What ingredients should I avoid?
There are a few ingredients that you want to watch out for. Dr. Nelson warns of a few specific ingredients to be on the lookout for.
“Items like BHA, melamine and artificial dyes are the products that I steer pet parents away from when choosing foods,” she said.
There is also a misconception that grains and corn are bad for dogs, when really they do serve a purpose aside from just a filler for pet food companies.
“Grains provide a healthy source of carbohydrates in pet food and meat meal is simply a dried end-product of of the cooking process and can contain high quality and digestible whole meat products,” explained Dr. Nelson.
However, it’s important to note that many of the grains used in kibble are not human-grade, which is why many vets recommend fresh food without preservatives and high-quality grains.
Why Trust Post Wanted by the New York Post
This article was written by Emma Sutton-Williams, New York Post Commerce Reporter. Proud dog mom to a Mini Sheepadoodle named Lucy, Emma routinely tests top-rated pet products with her pup to find the best recommendations for fellow pet owners. In search of the best dog food brands, leashes, harnesses and more, Emma taps veterinarians and experts like Cesar Millan, better known as the “Dog Whisperer,” for pet health advice, FAQs and training secrets. In addition to her work at the Post, Emma’s byline has appeared in Rolling Stone, Oprah Daily, Parents, InStyle, StyleCaster and more.